Mediating Effect of Competitive State Anxiety on the Relationship between Mood States and Perceived Performance Experienced by Asian Male Baseball Players from Universities in Choking under Pressure Situations

Background: The aim of the present study was to investigate the relationships between mood states and competitive state anxiety and perceived performance in Asian male baseball players from universities in choking under pressure situations during a game. An additional aim was to identify the mediating effect of competitive state anxiety on such relationships. Methods: A questionnaire was administered to 209 male baseball players from universities who wanted to enter a professional league. The mean age of study subjects was 20.25 years. Structural equation modeling and bootstrapping analyses were used to test hypotheses and analyze the mediation effect. Results: First, among mood states, higher confusion and higher tension predicted higher competitive state anxiety. Second, mood states had no significant influence on perceived performance. Third, higher competitive state anxiety predicted lower perceived performance. Lastly, competitive state anxiety had a complete mediating effect on the relationship between mood states and perceived performance. Conclusions: To help athletes perform to the best of their ability, psychological interventions should be provided with a greater focus on reducing competitive state anxiety during a game. And we believe that an intervention program with a greater focus on competitive state anxiety can provide a more realistic and effective assistance scheme which will prevent a sudden decrement in performance.

Asian male baseball players; mood states; competitive state anxiety; perceived performance; choking under pressure

[1] Choi BA. The contribution of emotional intelligence to sports psychology and performance of golf players. Journal of Golf Re-search. 2017; 11: 141–155.

[2] Spielberger CD. Current trends in theory and research on anxi-ety. In Spielberger CD (ed.) Anxiety: Current trends in theory and research 3–18. Academic Press: New York, NY. 1972.

[3] Park KH. A study about the effect of Taekwondo athlete’s com-petitive anxiety influencing individual performance [Unpub-lished master’s thesis]. Korea National Sport University. 2008.

[4] Yoon SJ, Irie K, Lee JH, Lim SM. Perfectionism, Mood States, and Choking in Asian University Baseball Players under Pres-sure during a Game. International Journal of Environmental Re-search and Public Health. 2021; 18: 12856.

[5] Otten M. Choking vs. clutch performance: A study of sport per-formance under pressure. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychol-ogy. 2009; 31: 583–601.

[6] Gucciardi DF, Longbottom J, Jackson B, Dimmock JA. Experi-enced Golfers’ Perspectives on Choking under Pressure. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology. 2010; 32: 61–83.

[7] Hill DM, Hanton S, Matthews N, Fleming S. A Qualitative Ex-ploration of Choking in Elite Golf. Journal of Clinical Sport Psy-chology. 2010; 4: 221–240.

[8] Mesagno C, Beckmann J. Choking under pressure: theoretical models and interventions. Current Opinion in Psychology. 2017; 16: 170–175.

[9] Hoja S, Jansen P. Mindfulness-based intervention for tennis players: a quasi-experimental pilot study. BMJ Open Sport and Exercise Medicine. 2019; 5: e000584.

[10] Hill DM, Hanton S, Fleming S, Matthews N. A re-examination of choking under pressure. European Journal of Sport Science. 2009; 9: 203–212.

[11] Sim J, Min K, Choi Y. The process for re-socialization and Des-ocialization of Independent Baseball players. Journal of Sport and Leisure Studies. 2020; 79: 275–286.

[12] Smith AL, Gould D. Introduction to the Special Issue on Con-temporary Youth Sport: Critical Issues and Future Directions. Kinesiology Review. 2019; 8: 145–149.

[13] Marchant D, Maher R, Wang J. Perspectives on choking in sport. In Papaioannou AG, Hackfort D, Hackfort D (eds.) Routledge Companion to Sport and Exercise Psychology: Global Perspec-tives and Fundamental Concepts 446. Routledge: Abingdon-on-Thames. 2014.

[14] Mesagno C, Geukes K, Larkin P. Choking under pressure: A review of current debates, literature, and interventions. In Mel-lalieu S, Hanton S (eds.) Contemporary Advances in Sport Psychology: A Review 148–174. Routledge: Abingdon-on-Thames. 2015.

[15] Bertollo M, Saltarelli B, Robazza C. Mental preparation strate-gies of elite modern pentathletes. Psychology of Sport and Ex-ercise. 2009; 10: 244–254.

[16] Cheon S, Lee D. The Effects of University Athletes’ Tenacity and Positive Psychological Capital on Perceived Performance. Journal of Sport and Leisure Studies. 2019; 76: 173–182.

[17] Cerin E, Szabo A, Hunt N, Williams C. Temporal patterning of competitive emotions: a critical review. Journal of Sports Sci-ences. 2000; 18: 605–626.

[18] Gill GS. Examining the impact of emotional intelligence and goal setting on basketball performance. Sport Journal. 2016; 1.

[19] Ismail M, Ismail AN. The effects of practice in mind (pim) train-ing on performance strategies used by professional university football players. Pertanika Journal of Social Sciences & Human-ities. 2019; 27: 1357–1365.

[20] Robazza C, Pellizzari M, Hanin Y. Emotion self-regulation and athletic performance: an application of the IZOF model. Psy-chology of Sport and Exercise. 2004; 5: 379–404.

[21] So Y. Relationship among Self-management, Sports Perfor-mance Strategies, and Perceived Performance of College Ath-letes. Journal of Sport and Leisure Studies. 2016; 65: 215–227.

[22] Lee U, Yoo H. The Effects of Psychological Skills Training on Mood States, Sports Performance Strategy and Perceived Per-formance of High School Swimmers in Slump. Korean Journal of Sport Psychology. 2020; 31: 107–122.

[23] Kim W. The Verification relationship among emotional intelli-gence, sport psychological skill, and performance of volleyball player. Korean Journal of Sports Science. 2018; 27: 395–404.

[24] Kim K, Choi H, Kim S. The Effects of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and Cognitive Emotion Regulation on Competitive State Anxiety of Adolescent Athletes. Korean Journal of Sports Science. 2018; 27: 329–340.

[25] Lee J, Lee J, Kang H. Literature Review on Competitive State Anxiety in Elite Athletes. Korean Journal of Sports Science. 2020; 9: 213–224.

[26] Song J, Yun W. The Influence of Psychological Stability of High School and University Soccer Players on Steady State of Compe-tition and Performance. Journal of the Korean Society for Well-ness. 2018; 13: 451–465.

[27] Hanton S, Thomas O, Maynard I. Competitive anxiety responses in the week leading up to competition: the role of intensity, di-rection and frequency dimensions. Psychology of Sport and Ex-ercise. 2004; 5: 169–181.

[28] Hill DM, Cheesbrough M, Gorczynski P, Matthews N. The Con-sequences of Choking in Sport: a Constructive or Destructive Experience? The Sport Psychologist. 2019; 33: 12–22.

[29] Kwon SH, Oh KL. A study on the relation amongst exercise sat-isfaction, competitive state anxiety and psychological factors in athletic performance according to soccer players team and posi-tion. The Korea Journal of Sports Science. 2016; 25: 425–436.

[30] Huh J, Ko K. A Case study of Psychological Support to Career Decision on High School Baseball Players. Journal of Sport and Leisure Studies. 2019; 78: 267–280.

[31] Lee HJ, Hong MS. Taekwondo poomsae athletes’ self-control, their trust in instructor, fairness of referee’s decision, compe-tition anxiety and perceived athletic performance. The Korea Journal of Sports Science. 2016; 25: 245–259.

[32] Ramis Y, Torregrosa M, Viladrich C, Cruz J. The Effect of Coaches’ Controlling Style on the Competitive Anxiety of Young Athletes. Frontiers in Psychology. 2017; 8: 572.

[33] Stephen SA, Habeeb CM, Arthur CA. Congruence of effi-cacy beliefs on the coach-athlete relationship and athlete anx-iety: Athlete self-efficacy and coach estimation of athlete self-efficacy. Psychology of Sport and Exercise. 2022; 58: 102062.

[34] Frijda NH. The emotions. Cambridge University Press: Cam-bridge, UK. 1986.

[35] Lazarus RS. Progress on a cognitive-motivational-relational the-ory of emotion. American Psychologist. 1991; 46: 819–834.

[36] Suinn RM. Seven steps to peak performance. Luber: Toronto, Canada. 1989.

[37] Lazarus RS. How Emotions Influence Performance in Compet-itive Sports. The Sport Psychologist. 2000; 14: 229–252.

[38] Pekrun R. Progress and open problems in educational emotion research. Learning and Instruction. 2005; 15: 497–506.

[39] Raab M, Lobinger B, Hoffmann S, Pizzera A, Laborde S (eds.) Performance psychology: Perception, action, cognition, and emotion. Academic Press: Cambridge, MA. 2015.

[40] Yang JE, Shin JT, Kim JS. The effects of a psychological skills training on competitive anxiety, intrinsic motivation, sports self-confidence, performance strategy and perceived performance of high school taekwondo players. Journal of Wellness. 2015; 10: 147–160.

[41] Cox, RH. Sport Psychology, Concepts and Applications. Wm C.: Dubuque, IA. 1990.

[42] Passer MW. Fear of Failure, Fear of Evaluation, Perceived Com-petence, and Self-esteem in Competitive-Trait-Anxious Chil-dren. Journal of Sport Psychology. 1983; 5: 172–188.

[43] Spielberger CD. Theory and research on anxiety; in Anxiety and behavior. Spielbergered. 1966; 3–22.

[44] Martens R. Sport Competition Anxiety Test. Human Kinetics Publishers: Champaign, IL. 1977.

[45] Jones G, Hanton S. Pre-competitive feeling states and directional anxiety interpretations. Journal of Sports Sciences. 2001; 19: 385–395.

[46] Pijpers JR, Oudejans RRD, Bakker FC. Anxiety-Induced Changes in Movement Behaviour during the Execution of a Complex whole-body task. The Quarterly Journal of Experimen-tal Psychology Section A. 2005; 58: 421–445.

[47] Black SJ, Weiss MR. The Relationship Among Perceived Coaching Behavior Perception of Ability and Motivation in Competitive age Group Swimmers. Journal of Sport and Exer-cise Psychology. 1992; 14: 309–325.

[48] Mamassis G, Doganis G. The effects of mental training program on junior’s pre-competitive anxiety, self-confidence, and tennis performance. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology. 2004; 16: 118–137.

[49] Cohn PJ. An Exploratory Study on Peak Performance in Golf. The Sport Psychologist. 1991; 5: 1–14.

[50] Jeong JB. The Structural Relationships among Self Manage-ment and Sport Coping, Risk Perceptions and Recognized Per-formances for teaching middle and high school Golfers [Unpub-lished doctoral dissertation]. Soongshil University. 2013.

[51] Yoon BI. The Structural Relationship of Judges Decision Per-ception, Sport Flow, Sport Confidence, and Perceived Perfor-mance in Taekwondo Players [Unpublished doctoral disserta-tion]. Chungbuk National University. 2014.

[52] Koo GY, Ruihley BJ, Dittmore SW. Impact of perceived on-field performance on sport celebrity source credibility. Sport Marketing Quarterly. 2012; 21: 147.

[53] Starkes JL. Motor expertise: Opening thoughts. In Starkes JL, Allard F (eds.) Cognitive issues in motor expertise 3–16. Else-vier: North-Holland. 1993.

[54] Cox R. Sport Psychology: Concepts and applications. 3rd edn. Brown & Benchmark Publishers: Dubuque, IA. 1994.

[55] Gould D, Krane V. The arousal-athletic performance relation-ship: Current status and future directions. In Horn TS (ed.) Ad-vances in sport psychology 119–141. Human Kinetics: Cham-paign, Il. 1992.

[56] Lazarus RS. From Psychological Stress to the Emotions: a History of Changing Outlooks. Annual Review of Psychology. 1993; 44: 1–21.

[57] Wrisberg CA. The Arousal-Performance Relationship. Quest. 1994; 46: 60–77.

[58] Gill DL. A Sport and Exercise Psychology Perspective on Stress. Quest. 1994; 46: 20–27.

[59] Gould D, Udry E. Psychological skills for enhancing perfor-mance. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. 1994; 26: 478–485.

[60] Hanin YL. Emotions and athletic performance: Individual zones of optimal functioning model. European Yearbook Sport Psy-chology. 1997; 1: 29–72.

[61] Kerr JH. Motivation and emotion in sport: Reversal theory. Psy-chology Press: East Sussex, UK. 1997.

[62] Males JR, Kerr JH. Stress, Emotion, and Performance in Elite Slalom Canoeists. The Sport Psychologist. 1996; 10: 17–36.

[63] Hong KD, Lee HS. The relationship of pre-competitive state anxiety and archery performance. Journal of Coaching Devel-opment. 2005; 7: 141–150.

[64] Kim JH. Relationship between competitive state anxiety and perceived performance to overtraining recognition in elite fenc-ing players. The Korean Journal of Sport. 2019; 17: 943–952.

[65] Landers DM, Boutcher SH. Arousal-performance relationships. In Willians JM (ed.) Applied Sport Psychology: Personal Growth to Peak Performance 197–218. 2nd edn. Mayfield: Mountain View, CA. 1998.

[66] Oh HS, Kim KY. A study on the competitive state anxiety and spirit of youth junior national badminton player. The Korean Journal of Sport. 2014; 12: 59–68.

[67] Shin GC. The Cause Relationship between Exercise Flow, Com-petitive State Anxiety and Recognized Performance of Taek-wondo Athletes [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. Kyungnam University. 2018.

[68] Mesagno C, Hill DM. Definition of choking in sport: Re-conceptualization and debate. International Journal of Sport Psy-chology. 2013; 44: 267–277.

[69] Hill DM, Carvell S, Matthews N, Weston NJV, Thelwell RRC. Exploring choking experiences in elite sport: the role of self-presentation. Psychology of Sport and Exercise. 2017; 33: 141–149.

[70] McNair DM, Lorr M, Droppleman LF. Manual for the Profile of Mood States. Educational and Industrial Testing Service: San Diego, CA. 1992.

[71] Park JU. Effects of sports counseling on the emotion and the self‐confidence of sports players under rehabilitation training af-ter sports injury [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. Sungshin Women’s University. 2013.

[72] Martens R, Burton D, Vealey R, Bump L, Smith D. Develop-ment and validation of the Competitive State Anxiety Inventory-2 (CSAI-2). In Martens R, Vealey R, Burton D (eds.) Competi-tive anxiety in sport 117–190. Human Kinetics: Champaign, IL. 1990.

[73] Kim DJ, Jeon JW. Application content and study method of the sport competition anxiety Test-2 for golf players. The Korea Journal of Sports Science. 2014; 23: 1457–1464.

[74] Song ES, Jung TS, Choi DH. The relationship among com-petition state anxiety, imagery types and psychological skills through psychological training program applied to shooting ath-letes. The Korea Journal of Sports Science. 2012; 21: 503–516.

[75] No KS. The proper methods of statistical analysis for disserta-tion: SPSS & AMOS. Hanbit Academy: Seoul, Republic of Ko-rea. 2019.

[76] Kim JH, Kim MK, Hong SH. A writing the structural equation model analysis. Communication books: Seoul, Republic of Ko-rea. 2015.

[77] Bae BR. Structural equation modeling with Amos 24: princi-ples and practice. Chung-Ram Press: Seoul, Republic of Korea. 2017.

[78] Hooper D, Coughlan J, Mullen MR. Structural Equation mod-elling: guidelines for determining model fit. Electron. Journal of Business Research Methods. 2008; 6: 53–60.

[79] Kline RB. Principles and practice of structural equation model-ing. 4th edn. Guilford Press : New York, NY. 2016.

[80] Coakley J. The Good Father: Parental Expectations and Youth Sports. Leisure Studies. 2006; 25: 153–163.

[81] Erdner SM, Wright CN. The relationship between family com-munication patterns and the self-efficacy of student-athletes. Communication & Sport. 2018; 6: 368–389.

[82] Choi J, Hong JE. Grounded Theory on College Athletes’ Per-fectionism and Retirement Preparation- is it helpful or harmful?Journal of the Korean Society for Wellness. 2019; 14: 185–202.

[83] Martens R, Vealey R, Burton D. Competitive Anxiety in sport. Human Kinetics: Champaing, IL. 1990.

[84] Hanin YL. A study of anxiety in sports. In Straub WF (ed.) Sport psychology: An analysis of athlete behavior 236-249. Mouve-ment Pubns: Ithaca, NY. 1980.

[85] Scanlan TK. Competitive stress and the child athlete. In John MS, Weinberg RS (eds.) Psychological foundations of sport 118-129. Human Kinetics: Champaign, IL. 1984.

[86] Cratty BJ. Psychology in contemporary sport: Guidelines for coaches and athletes. Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ. 1983.

[87] Singer RN. Motor Learning and Human Performance. Macmil-lan Publishing C.: NewYork, NY. 1980.