A study of job insecurity and life satisfaction in COVID-19: the multilevel moderating effect of perceived control and work–life balance programs

Background: The effect of COVID-19 on the manufacturing industry in China has resulted in increased employee psychological pressure and job insecurity. This study uses a theoretical model to identify the links between job insecurity and life satisfaction, and further explores the multilevel moderating effect underlying these links. Methods: Based on the conservation of resources theory, a hierarchical linear model is utilized to test the relationships among cross-level variables. The data comprises 528 valid questionnaires from 43 manufacturing companies in China. Results: The research results show that both perceived control (individual level) and work–life balance programs (organizational level) positively moderate the relationship between job insecurity and life satisfaction. Conclusions: This study contributes toward identifying the effect of employees’ psychological status and job insecurity on life satisfaction, and further confirms two different level moderators that alleviate the negative relationship between job insecurity and life satisfaction. Whether different genders have an effect on perception of life satisfaction is also considered, and the results show that men perceive significantly greater life satisfaction than women. Finally, based on the research findings, practical and theoretical implications are proposed.

Job insecurity; Life satisfaction; Perceived control; Work–life balance program; Multilevel analysis

[1] Guicciardi M, Pazzona R. The rebooting in sports and physical activities after COVID-19 Italian lockdown. Frontiers in Psy-chology. 2020; 11: 607233.

[2] Martinez-Martin N, Dasgupta I, Carter A, Chandler JA, Kellmeyer P, Kreitmair K, et al. Ethics of digital mental health during COVID-19: Crisis and opportunities. JMIR Mental Health. 2020; 7: e23776.

[3] Charoensukmongkol P, Phungsoonthorn T. The effectiveness of supervisor support in lessening perceived uncertainties and emo-tional exhaustion of university employees during the COVID-19 crisis: the constraining role of organizational intransigence. The Journal of General Psychology. 2020; 148: 431–450.

[4] Teng YM, Wu KS, Lin KL, Xu D. Mental health impact of COVID-19 on quarantine hotel employees in China. Risk Man-agement and Healthcare Policy. 2020; 13: 2743–2751.

[5] Blomqvist S, Xu T, Persitera P, Låstad L, Magnusson Hanson LL. Associations between cognitive and affective job insecurity and incident purchase of psychotropic drugs: a prospective co-hort study of Swedish employees. Journal of Affective Disor-ders. 2020; 266: 215–222.

[6] Greenhalgh L, Rosenblatt Z. Job Insecurity: toward Conceptual Clarity. Academy of Management Review. 1984; 9: 438–448.

[7] Cheng GH-, Chan DK-. Who Suffers more from Job Insecurity?A Meta-Analytic Review. Applied Psychology. 2008; 57: 272–303.

[8] De witte H, Pienaar J, De cuyper N. Review of 30 Years of Lon-gitudinal Studies on the Association between Job Insecurity and Health and well‐being: is there Causal Evidence? Australian Psychologist. 2016; 51: 18–31.

[9] Gilboa S, Shirom A, Fried Y, Cooper C. A meta-analysis of work demand stressors and job performance: examining main and moderating effects. Personnel Psychology. 2008; 61: 227–271.

[10] Richter A, Vander Elst T, De Witte H. Job insecurity and subse-quent actual turnover: Rumination as a valid explanation? Fron-tiers in Psychology. 2020; 11: 712–723.

[11] Sverke M, Hellgren J, Näswall K. No security: A meta-analysis and review of job insecurity and its consequences. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology. 2002; 7: 242–264.

[12] Vander Elst T, De Cuyper N, Baillien E, Niesen W, De Witte H. Perceived Control and Psychological Contract Breach as Expla-nations of the Relationships between Job Insecurity, Job Strain and Coping Reactions: towards a Theoretical Integration. Stress and Health. 2016; 32: 100–116.

[13] Piccoli B, Callea A, Urbini F, Chirumbolo A, Ingusci E, De Witte H. Job insecurity and performance: the mediating role of organizational identification. Personnel Review. 2017; 46: 1508–1522.

[14] Hobfoll SE. Social and Psychological Resources and Adapta-tion. Review of General Psychology. 2002; 6: 307–324.

[15] Lapierre LM, Allen TD. Work-supportive family, family-supportive supervision, use of organizational benefits, and problem-focused coping: implications for work-family conflict and employee well-being. Journal of Occupational Health Psy-chology. 2006; 11: 169–181.

[16] Karatepe OM, Baddar L. An empirical study of the selected consequences of frontline employees’ work–family conflict and family–work conflict. Tourism Management. 2006; 27: 1017–1028.

[17] Kausto J, Elo A, Lipponen J, Elovainio M. Moderating effects of job insecurity in the relationships between procedural justice and employee well-being: Gender differences. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology. 2005; 14: 431–452.

[18] Näswall K, Sverke M, Hellgren J. The moderating role of per-sonality characteristics on the relationship between job insecu-rity and strain. Work & Stress. 2005; 19: 37–49.

[19] Wang H, Lu C, Siu O. Job insecurity and job performance: the moderating role of organizational justice and the mediating role of work engagement. The Journal of Applied Psychology. 2015; 100: 1249–1258.

[20] Lam CF, Liang J, Ashford SJ, Lee C. Job insecurity and orga-nizational citizenship behavior: exploring curvilinear and mod-erated relationships. The Journal of Applied Psychology. 2015; 100: 499–510.

[21] Elst TV, De Cuyper N, De Witte H. The role of perceived con-trol in the relationship between job insecurity and psychosocial outcomes: moderator or mediator? Stress and Health. 2011; 27: e215–e227.

[22] Probst TM. Safety and insecurity: exploring the moderating ef-fect of organizational safety climate. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology. 2004; 9: 3–10.

[23] Wynn AT, Rao AH. Failures of Flexibility: how Perceived Con-trol Motivates the Individualization of Work–Life Conflict. ILR Review. 2020; 73: 61–90.

[24] Pallant JF. Development and validation of a scale to measure perceived control of internal states. Journal of Personality As-sessment. 2000; 75: 308–337.

[25] Hobfoll SE. Conservation of resources. a new attempt at con-ceptualizing stress. The American Psychologist. 1989; 44: 513–524.

[26] Hobfoll SE, Shirom A. Conservation of resources theory: Ap- plications to stress and management in the workplace. In Golem-biewski RT (ed.) Handbook of organizational behavior (pp. 57–81). Dekker Press: New York, NY. 2001.

[27] Wang M, Liao H, Zhan Y, Shi J. Daily Customer Mistreatment and Employee Sabotage against Customers:Examining Emotion and Resource Perspectives. Academy of Management Journal. 2011; 54: 312–334.

[28] Vohs KD, Heatherton TF. Self-regulatory failure: a resource-depletion approach. Psychological Science. 2000; 11: 249–254.

[29] Sonnentag S, Zijlstra FRH. Job characteristics and off-job activ-ities as predictors of need for recovery, well-being, and fatigue. The Journal of Applied Psychology. 2006; 91: 330–350.

[30] Jiang L, Lavaysse LM. Cognitive and Affective Job Insecurity: a Meta-Analysis and a Primary Study. Journal of Management. 2018; 44: 2307–2342.

[31] Folkman S, Lazarus RS. If it changes it must be a process: Study of emotion and coping during three stages of a college examina-tion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 1985; 48: 150–170.

[32] Boswell WR, Olson-Buchanan JB, Harris TB. I cannot Afford to have a Life: Employee Adaptation to Feelings of Job Insecurity. Personnel Psychology. 2014; 67: 887–915.

[33] Molino M, Cortese CG, Bakker AB, Ghislieri C. Do recovery experiences moderate the relationship between workload and work-family conflict? Career Development International. 2015; 20: 686–702.

[34] Xavier IM, Jepsen DM. The Impact of Specific Job Stressors on Psychological Contract Breach and Violation. Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing & Service Industries. 2015; 25: 534–547.

[35] Wallston KA, Wallston BS, Smith S, Dobbins CJ. Perceived con-trol and health. Current Psychology. 1987; 6: 5–25.

[36] Ajzen I. Perceived Behavioral Control, Self-Efficacy, Locus of Control, and the Theory of Planned Behavior1. Journal of Ap-plied Social Psychology. 2002; 32: 665–683.

[37] Philippaers K, De Cuyper N, Forrier A. Employability and per-formance: The role of perceived control and affective organiza-tional commitment. Personnel Review. 2019; 48: 1299–1317.

[38] Kiral Ucar G, Hasta D, Kaynak Malatyali M. The mediating role of perceived control and hopelessness in the relation between personal belief in a just world and life satisfaction. Personality and Individual Differences. 2019; 143: 68–73.

[39] Dong X, Zhao C, Yin H, Chen G. Work–family conflict affects job insecurity: the mediating role of core self-evaluation. Social Behavior and Personality: an International Journal. 2020; 48: 1–10.

[40] Debus ME, Unger D, König CJ. Job insecurity and performance over time: the critical role of job insecurity duration. Career De-velopment International. 2020; 25: 325–336.

[41] Tiwari DN, Tyagi SC. Impact of globalization on work-life bal-ance in IFFCO, Aonla, Bareilly. International Journal of Re-search in Commerce & Management. 2014; 5: 55–58.

[42] Sang KJC, Ison SG, Dainty ARJ. The job satisfaction of UK ar-chitects and relationships with work‐life balance and turnover intentions. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Man-agement. 2009; 16: 288–300.

[43] Smit BW. Successfully leaving work at work: the self-regulatory underpinnings of psychological detachment. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology. 2016; 89: 493–514.

[44] Sánchez-Vidal ME, Cegarra-Leiva D, Cegarra-Navarro JG. Gaps between managers’ and employees’ perceptions of work–life balance. The International Journal of Human Resource Man-agement. 2012; 23: 645–661.

[45] Chuang C, Liao H. Strategic human resource management in ser-vice context: taking care of business by taking care of employees and customers. Personnel Psychology. 2010; 63: 153–196.

[46] Nauman S, Zheng C, Naseer S. Job insecurity and work–family conflict. International Journal of Conflict Management. 2020; 31: 729–751.

[47] Richter A, Näswall K, Lindfors P, Sverke M. Job insecurity and work-family conflict in teachers in Sweden: Examining their re-lations with longitudinal cross-lagged modeling. PsyCh Journal. 2015; 4: 98–111.

[48] Eldridge D, Nisar TM. Employee and Organizational Impacts of Flexitime Work Arrangements. Articles. 2011; 66: 213–234.

[49] Lambert EG, Pasupuleti S, Cluse-Tolar T, Jennings M, Baker D. The Impact of Work-Family Conflict on Social Work and Hu-man Service Worker Job Satisfaction and Organizational Com-mitment: An exploratory study. Administration in Social Work. 2006; 30: 55–74.

[50] Feather NT, Rauter KA. Organizational citizenship behaviours in relation to job status, job insecurity, organizational commit-ment and identification, job satisfaction and work values. Jour-nal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology. 2004; 77: 81–94.

[51] Kushnir T, Melamed S. Work-load, perceived control and psy-chological distress in Type A/B industrial workers. Journal of Organizational Behavior. 1991; 12: 155–168.

[52] Diener E, Emmons RA, Larsen RJ, Griffin S. The Satisfaction with Life Scale. Journal of Personality Assessment. 1985; 49: 71–75.

[53] Jehn KA, Northcraft GB, Neale MA. Why Differences Make a Difference: a Field Study of Diversity, Conflict and Perfor-mance in Workgroups. Administrative Science Quarterly. 1999; 44: 741–763.

[54] Cappelli P, Hamori M. Are Franchises bad employer? Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 2008; 61: 147–162.

[55] Eldridge D, Nisar TM. The significance of employee skill in flexible work organizations. The International Journal of Human Resource Management. 2006; 17: 918–937.

[56] Farh JL, Hackett RD, Liang J. Individual level cultural values as moderators of perceived organizational support-employee out-comes relationships in China: Comparing the effects of power distance and traditionality. Academy of Management Journal. 2007; 50: 715–729.

[57] Hair JF, Black WC, Babin BJ, Anderson RE. Multivariate data analysis. 8th Edition. Andover UK: Cengage Learning EMEA. 2018.

[58] Kozlowski SWJ, Klein KJ. A multilevel approach to theory and research in organizations: Contextual, temporal, and emergent processes. In Klein KJ, Kozlowski SWJ (eds.) Multilevel the-ory, research, and methods in organizations: Foundations, ex-tensions, and new directions (pp. 3–90). Jossey-Bass: San Fran-cisco, CA. 2000.

[59] James LR, Demaree RG, Wolf G. Estimating within-group inter-rater reliability with and without response bias. Journal of Ap-plied Psychology. 1984; 69: 85–98.

[60] Chirumbolo A, Callea A, Urbini F. The effect of job insecurity and life uncertainty on everyday consumptions and broader life projects during COVID-19 pandemic. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2021; 18: 5363.

[61] Rocereto JF, Gupta SF, Mosca JB. The role of flextime appeal on family and work outcomes among active and non-active flextime users: A between groups and within groups’ analysis. Journal of Business Economics. 2011; 9: 57–66.

[62] Halpern DF. How time flexible work policies can reduce stress, improve health, and save time. Stress Health. 2005; 21: 157–168.

[63] Krausz M, Sagie A, Bidermann Y. Actual and preferred work schedule and scheduling control as determinants of job-related attitudes. Journal of Vocational Behavior. 2000; 56: 1–11.

[64] Podsakoff PM, Organ DW. Self-Reports in Organizational Re-search: Problems and Prospects. Journal of Management. 1986; 12: 531–544.

[65] Sonnentag S, Kruel U. Psychological detachment from work during off-job time: the role of job stressors, job involvement, and recovery-related self-efficacy. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology. 2006; 15: 197–217.

[66] Trzebiatowski T, Triana MDC. Family Responsibility Discrim-ination, Power Distance, and Emotional Exhaustion: when and why are there Gender Differences in Work–Life Conflict? Jour-nal of Business Ethics. 2020; 162: 15–29.